Judge drops 1 of 5 defendants from 9/11 Gitmo case

SFGate San Francisco Chronicle

MIAMI (AP) — A military judge has ruled that one of five prisoners at the Guantanamo Bay naval base charged in the September 11 attack should be tried separately from his co-defendants.

Army Col. James Pohl ruled Thursday that Ramzi Binalshibh should get a separate war crimes trial because legal issues that apply only to him are preventing the case from moving forward against the other defendants.

Binalshibh, of Yemen, and the four others are facing trial by military commission at the U.S. base in Cuba for planning and aiding the September 11, 2001, terrorist attack. They could get the death penalty if convicted. A trial date has not been set.

The case has bogged down over whether Binalshibh is mentally competent to stand trial and whether an investigation of defense team members has compromised his legal representation. Pohl said neither issue will be resolved soon.

Prosecutors had opposed severing any of the defendants from the case and had argued in court papers that all five played significant roles in the terrorist attacks. Binalshibh’s lead defense attorney, James Harrington, said his client preferred to be tried with the co-defendants, one of whom is Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, a Pakistani who is the self-proclaimed mastermind of the plot.

James Connell, a lawyer for Pakistani defendant Ammar al-Baluchi said the ruling to sever one defendant will likely allow the proceedings to move forward. A weeklong pretrial hearing is scheduled to start Aug. 11. “We can now return to the legal issues regarding the military commissions instead of the legal issues regarding Mr. Binalshibh.”

This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.